Online Therapy Youth, Equivalent to Treatment As Usual?

Обзор

With growing waiting lists in specialized youth mental health care (sGGZ) and shortages of care staff, finding creative solutions to respond to this scarcity issue is important. Online treatment is an example of this, which, especially for young people growing up in a digital age, can be an appropriate and accessible alternative to treatment at a physical location. Online treatment via video calling among youth, while researched and proven effective in a blended form, has not yet been sufficiently researched as a complete replacement for treatment at a physical location. As a result, the potential added value of online treatment for the pressing scarcity issue in healthcare is not yet sufficiently clear. This study therefore focuses on investigating the effectiveness of fully online treatment using two proven effective interventions: Eye Movement Desensitization and Reprocessing (EMDR) and Acceptance and Commitment Therapy (ACT) within the youth sGGZ. With the results of this research at GGZ-NHN, the investigators want to contribute to the development of guidelines and standards for the implementation of online treatments within Dutch youth mental health care.

Подробное описание

In recent years, there has been tension between young people's need for specialty mental health care (sGGZ) and the lack of sufficient available resources and staff. As a result, waiting lists have increased. To increase the accessibility and efficiency of care, online treatment through video calling is a promising method. Online treatment can help reduce waiting lists, as there are no limitations in terms of physical space and geographical proximity to clients and health care professionals, and it allows mental health professionals to work more efficiently and reach more young people, as they have no travel time and can plan flexibly from any location. An additional advantage of online treatment is its low threshold. Young people with mental health problems often face stigma and shame for physically going to a mental health facility. Online treatment via video call can remove this barrier and allow young people to access the care they need from their familiar surroundings.

It is plausible that fully online treatment with youth is at least as effective as treatment in a physical location, regardless of cultural origin, gender, or social environment, because youth are familiar with digital communication, the technical application has now been sufficiently developed, and blended treatment has been assessed as effective in research. However, it has not yet been sufficiently scientifically studied whether fully online treatment via video calling in youth is actually a worthy alternative to physical treatment in reducing mental health problems among youth.

This research project of GGZ Noord-Holland-Noord (GGZ-NHN), on which Drs. E. te Brake will receive her doctorate, therefore focuses on the effectiveness of fully online treatment within the youth sGGZ compared to regular treatment at a physical location. This study explicitly includes a role for experts by experience who, from the perspective of clients and relatives, contribute to the design and execution of the study and the implementation of the results into treatment practice.

The proposed research includes a Randomized Controlled Trial (RCT), specifically focused on two common therapies with adolescents in the sGGZ: Acceptance and Commitment Therapy (ACT) and Eye Movement Desensitization and Reprocessing (EMDR). Cognitive behavior therapy (CBT) could be an obvious choice because of its extensive knowledge and experience, as well as available scientific evidence. But the investigators prefer the more generalist ACT because CBT uses a separate protocol for each target group. As a third-generation form of therapy, ACT is a suitable intervention because its universal protocol is applicable to a broad target group. Moreover, ACT has been shown to be not inferior to cognitive behavioral therapy in terms of effectiveness. The methodology shows significant improvements in depressive symptoms, quality of life, and perception of competence.

Treatment will be protocolized according to the guidelines prescribed by the manual for this purpose. The protocol used is specifically intended for the target group aged 15-25. However, it is known that adolescents between 12 and 15 can also benefit well from ACT. Age-appropriate adjustments in language use will be applied here. In addition, EMDR will be investigated for trauma-specific symptoms, as digital tools are available with EMDR that allow for a good comparison with EMDR in a physical location.

Because an RCT generates reliable and generalizable information, and the investigators examine two commonly used interventions in the mental health system, the study fits well with policymakers' effectiveness-evidence criteria. If it turns out that fully online treatment is a worthy alternative to treatment at a physical location, then this lays a foundation for online work. It thus contributes to the low threshold, accessibility, and affordability of youth mental health care.

Вмешательства

• Поведенческое EMDR
  Eye Movement Desensitization and Reprocessing (EMDR) is a therapy designed to alleviate the distress associated with traumatic memories.
• Поведенческое ACT
  Acceptance and Commitment Therapy (ACT) is an action-oriented approach to psychotherapy that stems from traditional behavior therapy and cognitive behavioral therapy. Clients learn to stop avoiding, denying, and struggling with their inner emotions and, instead, accept that these deeper feelings are appropriate responses to certain situations and should not prevent them from moving forward in their lives. The ACT Your Way method is specifically designed for young people.

Первичные конечные точки

• Change in the level of psychological flexibility (for the ACT arms), as measured by the AFQ-Y. [Срок оценки: At baseline, +/- 3-months after start treatment, and at 6-months after completion of intervention (equals +/- 9 months after baseline assessment)]
• Change in the degree of overall symptomatic distress, as measured by the Youth Outcome questionnaire (YOQ) [Срок оценки: At baseline, +/- 3-months after start treatment, and at 6-months after completion of intervention (equals +/- 9 months after baseline assessment)]
• Change in post-traumatic symptoms (for the EMDR arms), as measured by the KJTS EMDR questionnaire [Срок оценки: At baseline, +/- 3-months within treatment, and at 6-months after completion of intervention (equals +/- 9 months after baseline assessment)]
• Change in the degree of societal recovery, as measured by the kidsscreen-27. [Срок оценки: At baseline, +/- 3-months after start treatment, and at 6-months after completion of intervention (equals +/- 9 months after baseline assessment)]

Вторичные конечные точки (1)

• Differences in the therapeutic relationship, as measured by the WAV-12 (work alliance questionnaire) [Срок оценки: At +/- 1 1/2 month after start treatment]

Критерии участия

Критерии включения

• Adolescents aged 12-18 years who would benefit from ACT or EMDR within the SGGZ, as determined by the screeners at registration or current primary practitioner.
• Client is stable, i.e. there is no serious crisis (to be determined by screener cq primary practitioner)
• Sufficient command of the Dutch language to complete the questionnaires.
• Client does not participate in other (intervention) studies

Критерии исключения

• Clients who are crisis-prone or enter in crisis
• Clients who are in forced care (wvggz)

Критерии приведены из реестра в оригинале (на английском). Окончательную оценку соответствия проводит исследовательский центр.

Здоровые добровольцы: Да

Дизайн исследования

Распределение

Рандомизированное

Модель

Параллельные группы

Маскирование

Двойное слепое

Основная цель

Лечение

Центры проведения

Нидерланды · 1 центр

• GGZ NHN — Alkmaar

Публикации

• Midgley N, Guerrero-Tates B, Mortimer R, Edbrooke-Childs J, Mechler J, Lindqvist K, Hajkowski S, Leibovich L, Martin P, Andersson G, Vlaescu G, Lilliengren P, Kitson A, Butler-Wheelhouse P, Philips B. The Depression: Online Therapy Study (D:OTS)-A Pilot Study of an Internet-Based Psychodynamic Treatment for Adolescents with Low Mood in the UK, in the Context of the COVID-19 Pandemic. Int J Environ PMID 34948601
• Ravens-Sieberer U, Auquier P, Erhart M, Gosch A, Rajmil L, Bruil J, Power M, Duer W, Cloetta B, Czemy L, Mazur J, Czimbalmos A, Tountas Y, Hagquist C, Kilroe J; European KIDSCREEN Group. The KIDSCREEN-27 quality of life measure for children and adolescents: psychometric results from a cross-cultural survey in 13 European countries. Qual Life Res. 2007 Oct;16(8):1347-56. doi: 10.1007/s11136-007-924 PMID 17668292
• Porter CM, Galloghly E, Burbach FR. The effective delivery of digital CBT: a service evaluation exploring the outcomes of young people who completed video conferencing therapy in 2020. The Cognitive Behaviour Therapist. 2022;15:e27. doi:10.1017/S1754470X22000216
• Pelzer, A. et al (2022), K. De balans is zoek in Jeugdzorgland. Kind Adolesc Prakt 21, 34-36
• Schueller SM, Stiles-Shields C, Yarosh L. Online Treatment and Virtual Therapists in Child and Adolescent Psychiatry. Child Adolesc Psychiatr Clin N Am. 2017 Jan;26(1):1-12. doi: 10.1016/j.chc.2016.07.011. Epub 2016 Oct 15. PMID 27837935
• Stinckens, Nele & Ulburghs, A. & Claes, Laurence. (2009). De werkalliantie als sleutelelement in het therapiegebeuren: Meting met behulp van de WAV-12, de Nederlandstalige verkorte versie van de Working Alliance Inventory. Tijdschrift Klinische Psychologie. 39. 44-60.
• Schraven, J., et al. (2023) ACT your way, kwaliteit van het protocol en eerste bevindingen van een pilot- effectonderzoek bij adolescenten met een recidiverende depressie
• caleidoZorg & CZ (2023) Tijd effectiviteit van WeMind vs. Lightbar bij EMDR-therapie in een klinische populatie

Идентификаторы

NCT: NCT06617663 · GGZNHNETB2024

Первоисточники (государственные реестры)

• ClinicalTrials.gov (NIH, США)

Открыть это исследование на ClinicalTrials.gov ↗